Article / 12 September 2014 at 10:09 GMT

This isn't brave Scotland, it's foolish

Chairman, Saxo Capital Markets UK Limited / Saxo Bank
United Kingdom
  • GBPUSD could plummet to 1.40 on a Yes vote
  • Latest YouGov poll Friday swings vote slightly to No camp at 52%
  • Four scenarios face Scotland if independence wins the day September 18

By Nick Beecroft

It is undoubtedly the case that a ‘Yes’ vote on September 18 will lead to short-term mayhem. While I want to emphasise here that this is not our central expectation – and today's YouGov poll shows a swing back towards the No vote at 52% – it is a tail-risk scenario of which investors should be aware.

Sterling and gilts will come under severe pressure, with the distinct possibility that sterling suffers a fall in the range of 10-20% against a dollar which is at last beginning to flourish due to the perception that rate rises from the US Federal Reserve may come earlier than expected.

That rise may come as early as the first quarter of 2015.

GBP/USD faces 1.40 nightmare

Buying volatility may still be the best trade, and although that ship has just left port, there may still be time before the vote to profitably buy options. During the 1992 ERM crisis and the global financial crisis in 2008, one-month GBP/USD volatility hit 30%.

The most damaging dynamic for sterling, and the UK economy, would be the enormous uncertainty created by the inevitably extended and fractious period of negotiation that would be necessary to determine what currency an independent Scotland would, (or could), use, how much current UK government debt Scotland would take on board, and how relevant assets would be split, including North Sea oil.

Even the ‘yes’ campaign envisages full legal independence will only be implemented in March 2016, but this is hopelessly optimistic – at least three years is a more realistic guess.


What will happen to North Sea oil in the event of a Yes victory? Photo: Thinkstock

Fantastic four

In reality, an Independent Scotland would have four choices with regard to its future currency.

1) Currency union with the UK 

It would be most desirable from the point of view of Scotland’s banks, as they would retain the support of the Bank of England. The only problem is that all major UK parties have said they would not agree to a union, and so the irony anyway is that under a currency union, to have any chance whatsoever of gaining Westminster’s agreement to the same, Scotland would have to cede monetary and fiscal power to the UK.

Otherwise we would be creating another Frankenstein, bearing an uncanny resemblance to the euro; a half-completed chimera that would ultimately come to a disastrous end. 

2) Sterlingisation

The scary implication for Scotland would be that there would be no more ‘lender of last resort’ in Threadneedle Street for Scottish banks, so they would need to be much more heavily capitalized than UK or international competitors, effectively rendering them uncompetitive and uneconomic. 

This solution has been employed in Panama and Montenegro. Actually, whatever currency
regime Scotland adopts, the banks would have to re-domicile to the UK and there would be no legal right for the Scottish Banks, (Bank of Scotland, Clydesdale and RBS), to issue notes.  

3) A new currency

Fine, but in that case the Scottish people had better get used to much more expensive borrowing, (on both a national and personal level), as the new Central Bank of Scotland would have to maintain much higher rates to defend this new baby of a currency and markets would demand much higher returns to buy Scottish ‘Gilts’. 

There would be huge capital flight as businesses rush to sell Scottish-based assets, Alex  Salmond’s promise of a corporate tax rate that is 3% below the UK’s will hardly be enough to prevent this, and depositors will be queuing up to remove their money from Scottish-based banks no longer backed by The Old Lady. This would be a massively volatile currency, with concomitant costs for Scottish exporters. 

Presumably there would be an attempt to peg to the pound, as Denmark does to the euro.
Scotland could attempt to build up reserves over a long time by running budget surpluses, but deficit current estimates put a Scottish budget deficit at 14% without oil, and with oil maybe 5- 8%, but oil revenues will decline to a miniscule £1-2 billion per year on average in the 2020s. This compares with a UK deficit of 5% this year, with budget balance projected by 2017. A massive austerity drive, or much higher taxes, would be required. 

Very sad and very unnecessary. 

4) Join the euro

A very long game, as Scotland would first have to successfully apply for EU membership, and do the Scottish people really want to join the euro club, with monetary policy to be set by the European Central Bank, usually to suit Germany? This is option 1), but worse.


This could be one of the worst of all the scenarios
facing Scotland if it votes Yes. Photo: Thinkstock

-- Edited by Martin O'Rourke

Nick Beecroft is chairman and senior market analyst at Saxo Capital Markets UK

Juhani Huopainen Juhani Huopainen
I think some sort of dual currency system, with Scottish *whatever it would be called* and pound both being legal tender, with the Scottish *whatever* floating from the start. All of the choices for an independent Scotland are terrible, so perhaps by choosing two terrible options, their combined effect would be less than either one's alone. This is something that would probably be the optimal way to leave the euro, too.
Nick Beecroft Nick Beecroft
Still a terrifying prospect i would suggest!
Juhani Huopainen Juhani Huopainen
I agree. While Scotland's independence would not bring in the locusts and the four horsemen to either London or Edinburgh, the amount of friction, extra work and uncertainty it would bring... plus the political costs. While I don't think political costs normally matter much, in this case it could lead to weird, strange, populist policies, as 10 Downing Street would be desperate to look strong and votable.


The Saxo Bank Group entities each provide execution-only service and access to permitting a person to view and/or use content available on or via the website is not intended to and does not change or expand on this. Such access and use are at all times subject to (i) The Terms of Use; (ii) Full Disclaimer; (iii) The Risk Warning; (iv) the Rules of Engagement and (v) Notices applying to and/or its content in addition (where relevant) to the terms governing the use of hyperlinks on the website of a member of the Saxo Bank Group by which access to is gained. Such content is therefore provided as no more than information. In particular no advice is intended to be provided or to be relied on as provided nor endorsed by any Saxo Bank Group entity; nor is it to be construed as solicitation or an incentive provided to subscribe for or sell or purchase any financial instrument. All trading or investments you make must be pursuant to your own unprompted and informed self-directed decision. As such no Saxo Bank Group entity will have or be liable for any losses that you may sustain as a result of any investment decision made in reliance on information which is available on or as a result of the use of the Orders given and trades effected are deemed intended to be given or effected for the account of the customer with the Saxo Bank Group entity operating in the jurisdiction in which the customer resides and/or with whom the customer opened and maintains his/her trading account. When trading through your contracting Saxo Bank Group entity will be the counterparty to any trading entered into by you. does not contain (and should not be construed as containing) financial, investment, tax or trading advice or advice of any sort offered, recommended or endorsed by Saxo Bank Group and should not be construed as a record of ourtrading prices, or as an offer, incentive or solicitation for the subscription, sale or purchase in any financial instrument. To the extent that any content is construed as investment research, you must note and accept that the content was not intended to and has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such, would be considered as a marketing communication under relevant laws. Please read our disclaimers:
- Notification on Non-Independent Invetment Research
- Full disclaimer

Check your inbox for a mail from us to fully activate your profile. No mail? Have us re-send your verification mail