Article / 16 April 2012 at 8:56 GMT

Are social media companies a new tech bubble?

Peter Bo Kiaer Peter Bo Kiaer
Strategist & Equity Analyst / Private
Denmark

Since history tends to repeat itself, it's a fair enough question: are today's social media companies as overvalued as many of the dot-com companies that collapsed with the IT bubble of the late 1990s?

Most of these questions arise from generalizations based on media coverage of the coming Facebook IPO and valuation on, for example, LinkedIn. These are the new social media and do not represent the overall IT investment universe.

In the table below a row of different “IT” companies are listed. It shows some of the different sections of the technology market and the valuations applied to the more well-known companies.

Table of IT companies PE level

The incumbents are not valued at high multiples and are not prone to a large correction based on a changed valuation. The further you go down the table, the more software and social media is represented. Looking at LinkedIn, the consensus valuation is 700 times earnings for 2012 and on Facebook the market is talking about a level of 100 times earnings. I have calculated my own level to be at best 55 times.

The new companies are bubbly
I think the social media valuation has a 2000 bubble flavor. The overall tendency is to incorporate all the opportunities and extrapolate growth and finally assume market leadership. This will generally result in super high expectations. The big risk is – are investors compensated for the risk they are taking? Some will reference to Google as a benchmark of what to expect, as the price has risen well over the years and rewarded the investors. But this is one case and many others have crumbled.

It is probable that we will see the Facebook IPO in May 2012. This will take a lot of attention and there will be arguments for high and low valuation. My best guess is that the “dream” will win a least in the short term. Valuation will be lifted to high level as any little opportunity is converted to earnings and market value.

The true test will come later probably after a few quarters that is end of 2012 or early 2013. Are there any hiccups and is Facebook rewarding new investors or was the opportunities just a dream after all?


Users don't like feeling 'targeted'

What can change the perception other than hard facts on earnings and revenue? Social Media and business is actually a difficult construct. There are unwritten rules of how to engage and act and this goes user to user and social site to user.

Taking the latter - it cost money to develop and host a site, so a revenue stream is necessary and users are aware of this. But users don't like feeling too 'targeted' as prey for revenue. The more the site extracts revenue and at the same time annoys users, the higher the risk of users migrating to other opportunities. When do you step over this invisible line?

In the case of Facebook, it would be devastating if other sites would suddenly become the flavor-of-the-moment and millions of users changed site. This can over time create a “tsunami” and crumble the existing business model. Users are fickle and investors should have this in mind when investing.

Can a social media bubble damage the economy?
Would difficulty in Facebook, Google, LinkedIn or Twitter or other Social Media sites have potential negative repercussion on the fragile economies in US and Europe? No. There is no linkage to the financial sector which is the main culprit behind the current  state of the economies.

If the market value of Facebook etc. disappears if would be a blow to each investor, but on a larger scale it would mean nothing. Social Media is part of a part of the economy and not the whole sector.

2y
NannaArnadottir NannaArnadottir
This is especially interesting in light of Facebook buying the social media photosharing comp Instagram last week for a billion dollars. I get that they did it to strengthen their mobile presence but honestly now, Instagram is a free app, no revenue and has 13 employees! Imagine that, 1 billion, 13 employees!
2y
Peter Bo Kiaer Peter Bo Kiaer
It is mentioned that the Instagram payment of USD $1 bn is in cash and stock. I havent got the split. But the larger the stock ratio is the more it is like in the 2000 bubble. If your stock is overpriced the you are able to buy other companies just by handing them "your own printed money". Many founders of companies around year 2000 ended up getting nothing for their "master pieces" as the funny money was just - funny. Sad but true.
1y
Prashant Prashant
One way to measure value of the company can be how critical is it for rest of the world. People/ organizations are ready to pay to Microsoft/ Cisco/ Apple etc for their services. But most of the facebook users will seldom like to pay facebook to get an account created. Secondly, will we really miss facebook just in case it stops operating as of this second.
1y
NannaArnadottir NannaArnadottir
I think I would miss it but I would never pay for it, but that's because I am targeted by ads like everyone else. Marketers are the one's who pay for Facebook, the user's identity, likes, demgraphic, that's valuable information. I think some people might consider paying for Facebook if it meant they were commercial free (the way that Spotify operates for example)
1y
Jomar Jomar
Peter, I absolutely agree with you that Social companies have that 2000 tech bubble feel. Back then the internet, its capabilities were overestimated not understood and the infrastructure still underdeveloped whilst at the same time overvalued. Today the social media landscape shares many of those traits, but many remember the impact of the .com bubble, and are a bit more wary.
One point of interest is that Linkedin have just announced the acquisition of Slideshare. Just like the Instagram acquisition by Facebook (As metnioned by Nanna), it looks like the social companies that have no revenue, are still valued by the larger fish, with revenue who are after a new audience.
Interesting times indeed...

Disclaimer

The Saxo Bank Group provides an execution-only service and all information provided on Tradingfloor.com is solely for general information. When trading through Tradingfloor.com your contracting Saxo Bank Group entity will be the counterparty to any trading entered into by you. Tradingfloor.com does not contain (and should not be construed as containing) financial, investment, tax or trading advice or advice of any sort offered, recommended or endorsed by Saxo Bank Group and should not be construed as a record of our trading prices, or as an offer, incentive or solicitation for the subscription, sale or purchase in any financial instrument. Saxo Bank Group will not be liable for any losses that you may sustain as a result of any investment decision made in reliance on information which is available as part of the Tradingfloor.com or as a result of the use of the Tradingfloor.com. Any information which could be construed as investment research has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such should be considered as a marketing communication. Furthermore it is not subject to any prohibition on dealing ahead of the dissemination of investment research. Please read our disclaimers:
- Notification on Non-Independent Investment Research
- Full disclaimer

Show latest activity
Dismiss
Sorry, there was a problem communicating with the TradingFloor.com servers. We are working hard to solve this. Please try again later.
Oops! There was a problem communicating with the OpenAPI Portfolio service.
Oops! There was a problem communicating with the OpenAPI History service.
Oops! There was a problem communicating with the OpenAPI Reference service.
Oops! There was a problem communicating with the OpenAPI Root service.
Oops! There was a problem communicating with the OpenAPI Trading service.
Sorry, there was a problem communicating with the Financial Calender servers. We are working hard to solve this. Please try again later.
Check your inbox for a mail from us to fully activate your profile. No mail? Have us re-send your verification mail